Good ones for this are the harry potter series, holes, the chronicles of narnia series, and where. What are some of the differences and similarities between. Mar 04, 2010 ever read a book, and then see the movie of the story. The movie is never going to have as much detail as the book did, but they did a good job making the movie as close as possible to the book. The movie is not the most detailed but it does get its point across. We get to wanting and when we get to wanting its bad for them. It was later made into a movie of the same name plot summary. Untitled document nightjohn compare and contrast essay. In the movie roy finds out iris is pregnant during the last game. They have entertained countless generations of people that they are almost always in anybodys most loved things to do list. The book talks more about the black slaves and nightjohn teaching sarny.
Nightjohn, a novel by gary paulsen, is set during the time of slavery and has many conflicts. The movie has plenty of the qualities one would expect from a disney. A searing picture of slavery, sometime in the 19th century at an unspecified place in the south. Watching a movie after reading the book is a wonderful way to encourage students to think critically about how each medium presented roughly the same information. Knowing that the penalty for reading is dismemberment nightjohn still retumed to slavery to teach others how to read. These are the main elements of life of pi, the 127minute ang lee film, released this week, that many are hailing as a masterpiece and a likely oscar nominee. Vocabulary words questions movie book comparison chart is the final project. Differences between i am legend book vs movie page 1. Jan 18, 2016 so maybe we are just insane, hoping for once they will do the book justice, but maybe this isnt the only reason we are insane. Her job is to take care of the white familys son as well as spitting tobacco on the roses to keep bugs away. The film is about a young slave girl named sarny, played by allison jones, who lives a hopeless life on a southern plantation. Nightjohn, a young adult novel by gary paulsen 1993, takes place shortly before the. Nightjohn study guide questions chapter 4 read chapter 4 of nightjohn on your own silently today pages 4258. It is about slavery in the american south shortly before the time of the american civil war.
Characterization the personalities and decisions of the characters. November marks the release of several movies based on young adult novels, which makes it the perfect time for this kind of study. Most people like one or the other, but i think the two complement each other because of the varied stances taken on the main character himself. Nightjohn has escaped more than once, but courageously returns to share his knowledge with those who have no way of knowing the world beyond their. Her chief duties at the plantation of clel waller beau bridges are serving at table, spitting tobacco juice on roses to prevent bugs, and secretly conveying intimate messages between wallers wife, callie kathleen york, and dr. Nightjohn is a 1996 american television film directed by charles burnett. It includes questions, charts, a scaffolded compare and contrast essay template, and more. While some people prefer to read the book first and others want to see the movie before reading the book, there is value in comparing books and movies.
Jan 01, 1993 nightjohn is a book that gives readers a whole new view on slavery. Interestingly enough, it wasnt until i dropped all expectations that the movie would be like the. Did the setting in the movie look like you had imagined it. The story of nightjohn the slave teaching sarney and the other slaves to read. These details are woven into the story without it seeming heavy handed. He is responsible for researching the story to find the intent of. Writing a book is a lot easier than making a movie. The book nightjohn written by gary pualsen and the movie directed by charles burnett. Differences between movies and books compare the difference. Unbroken, the movie, is based on the bestselling book by laura hillenbrand. But i have to say, this one gave me a run for my money. There were also tiny details that were precisely the same. Movie and book are two mediums of entertainment that have been around for quite some time now, books obviously being the older of the two.
Nightjohn is about a man who travels by night from plantation to plantation to teach other. The book and movie nightjohn mostly similar settings but there is some differences. Unbroken the life of louie zamperini is an incredible one. Have students share their observations with the class. Pass out copies of the book and movie comparisoncontrast guide, which asks them to determine how different elements of the story are alike and different, and ask students to complete the guide in pairs or small groups. Sarnysarny, a female slave at the waller plantation, first. There are may similarities and also many differences between the two the book is by far more interesting and more detailed then the movie. In the opening we are shown that sarnys mother is sold away after sarny turns out to.
Which is a shame, because there are a number of tremendous zombie narratives out there, titles that genuinely do something new and exciting with the horror subgenre, including the topic of todays discussion, m. The difference between movies and books is how they tell the story. The book seemed to focus a lot more on the cruelty of slavery then the movie did. Knowing that the penalty for reading is dismemberment, nightjohn still returned to slavery to teach others how to read. School library journal, starred among the most powerful of paulsens works, this impeccable researched novel sheds light on cruel truths in american history as it traces the experiences of a 12yearold slave girl in the 1850s. The narrator and protagonist of the story is a young female african.
It seems that the big bookrelated debate these days is paper vs. What makes both the book and the movie interesting. It showed how awful these people could be, and it made me wonder if all. Share your thoughts books are often made into movies. In some cases, movies and books perform the same function particularly in cases where both the book and the movie are based on similar stories thus have related content. Nightjohn is a story that is set in the south during the time of slavery. The novel is set on the waller plantation in the southern united states in the early 1800s. A gathering of old men 1987, sudie and simpson 1990, black cloud 2004, a raisin in the sun 2008, ellen foster 1997. Hes a man who seemed to live nine lives before finally dying at the age of 97 just last year mere months before the movie about his life came out. The novel and movie, the outsiders, had many similarities and many differences. Reading a book can be nice but thanks to movies all the work of deciphering the message of the story is done through the director of the motion picture. Nightjohn is a young adult novel by gary paulsen, first published in 1993. Vocabulary words questions moviebook comparison chart. For years, i was part of this insanity and was continuously let down by the parts they left out, the characters they dropped, their wrong choice in actors, etc.
For example, last night i streamed the movie, nightjohn 1996, from netflix and now i see that is was adapted from gary paulsens young adult book, nightjohn. This book is a must to include for your slavery unit or black history month. The book covered a lot more aspects of the story than the movie did, and the book focused on the bigger more important parts. Disney channel premiere film based on the book and compare the movie to the novel. Then i watched the movie version of the same story. Nightjohn compare and contrast by annie donahoe on prezi. Books from our mouths, to writing and finally to film, the way we tell stories has evolved over time and i must say thank god for its advancements. Every household should have the movie or the book or both as i do. Aug 31, 2011 knowing that the penalty for reading is dismemberment nightjohn still retumed to slavery to teach others how to read. Gary paulsens nightjohn, published in 1993, gives middle grade and high school students a realistic depiction of the worst of southern slaveowners during the time just before the. The movie isnt able to show in such detail how often she goes back and just how many connections are made. Differences between the natural book vs movie page 1. Free use these two printables after you have read the book and then seen the movie version.
The book nightjohn by gary paulsen is about a girl named sarny who is enslaved on a plantation. The novel nightjohn is about slaves who suffered the pains of torture and death in order to attain the key to freedom. It truly points out the importance of a must for reading and having an education. Ever read a book, and then see the movie of the story. Make sure to answer all of the parts of the questions. To know things, for us to know things, is bad for them. This 7page guide includes the following with every chapter. Supersummary, a modern alternative to sparknotes and cliffsnotes, offers highquality study guides that feature detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, quotes, and essay topics.
Best of all, it can be used over and over again with any book that has a movie companion. They will hear about the endless beatings, the harassment, and cruelty that these people suffered simply because of the country they came from and the color of their skin. Jan 23, 2015 the story of nightjohn the slave teaching sarney and the other slaves to read. The differences between all quiet on the western front movie and book, along with similarities.
Sarny learned how to read and write in both movie and book. Everyone wants to be the next kindle, and theres no shortage of opinions on whether the ipad is a better book reader. Film is a column comparing books to the film adaptations they spawn, often discussing them on a plotpointbyplotpoint basis. This onepage guide includes a plot summary and brief analysis of nightjohn by gary paulsen. Details that make the book and the movie different. Movie into the wild happens to be my favorite book, and also one of my favorite movies. Free essays from bartleby comparing and contrasting the movie and the book nightjohn the young adult novel nightjohn depicts the plight of enslaved. Nightjohn by gary paulsen questions, vocabulary, movie. For a no prep way to have students compare and contrast a book with its movie, check out my book vs. Gary paulsens nightjohn is a middle gradeyoung adult novel about a twelve yearold girl in the time of slavery in the american south. Book 675 words 3 pages comparing and contrasting the movie and the book nightjohn the young adult novel nightjohn depicts the plight of enslaved africanamericans from the pointofview of an adolescent so that readers can feel as well as learn about the difficulties experienced by slaves in the antebellum south. Browse book to movie comparison resources on teachers pay teachers. Great for comparing and contrasting and thinking critically about how the movie was made. Nightjohn should be required reading and discussing for all middle grade and high school students.
Readers will get an inside view of what really happened in the life of a plantation slave. A man named nightjohn who is also enslaved on the same plantation started to teach sarny how to read and write. Get an answer for what are some of the differences and similarities between the movie and the book beloved. Compare and contrast a book and movie activities teaching.
Comparing and contrasting the movie and the book nightjohn the young adult novel nightjohn depicts the plight of enslaved africanamericans from the pointofview of an adolescent so that readers can feel as well as learn about the difficulties experienced by slaves in the antebellum south. He played both the 19 year old and 35 year old roy. The character has the same name in both the book and the movie. Comparison and analysis of similar and different details in the novel outsiders and its film adaptation. Both novel and movie are really great but i think the book was better. Books are windows to any world, and those worlds are only limited by ones imagination. Nightjohn, unlike most tv movies, sticks in your mind long after its over, partly because scripter bill cain has turned gary paulsens book into a multileveled portrait of precivil war south.
Nightjohn himself was once a free escaped slave who returns on his own to teach others to read. Some people prefer one over the other, but they have equal merits. Nightjohn by gary paulsen meet your next favorite book. Coupled with the movie, you have one eye opener in short form to make the historical impact necessary. With a book you can describe places that come out of your imagination, which could never become reality no matter how hard hollywood tries. Movies and books, as stated previously, are two mediums of entertainment.
Even with my appreciation for the movie the effects, the way it was shot, and, of course, the actors who were amazing, by the way it still didnt cut it for me. Compares the movie nightjohn directed by charles burnett and the book nightjohn by gary pualsen. Mar 27, 2011 movie and book are two mediums of entertainment that have been around for quite some time now, books obviously being the older of the two. Some similarities in the both the book and the movie were the names of the main characters, sarny. The reasons the author considers the book better then the movie. As a closure activity, ask students to share why they think some of the. Comparing and contrasting the nightjohn book and movie. Sarny, young enough not to have experienced the rape that will come inexorably with child bearing age, tells how she learned to read, and at what cost. Some people argue that watching is better than reading but such an argument. Describe one way the movie and the book were the same. Characterization the personalities and decisions of the characters plot what happened the events, and.
The first settings are different were sarny in the movie. Comparing and contrasting the movie and the book nightjohn the young adult novel nightjohn depicts the plight of enslaved africanamericans. Pass out copies of the book and movie comparison contrast guide, which asks them to determine how different elements of the story are alike and different, and ask students to complete the guide in pairs or small groups. Sarny allison jones, a 12yearold slave girl in the antebellum south, faces a relatively hopeless life. Write the answers to the questions below and on the back side. Nightjohni didnt know what letters was, not what they meant, but i thought it might be something i wanted to know. And twelveyearold sarny is willing to take the risk to learn. Set in the 1850s, gary paulsens groundbreaking new novel is unlike anything else the awardwinning author has written. Nightjohn is bought by waller for one thousand dollars.
The book and the movie of the outsiders are two very different stories. Sometimes i see a movie and learn later that it was adapted from a book. Write a 5 essay comparing what is similar and contrasting what is different in the book nightjohn and the movie nightjohn. See more ideas about compare and contrast, books vs movies and the lorax book. In case youre not familiar, into the wild is based on the true story of chris. Nightjohn is a book that gives readers a whole new view on slavery. So maybe we are just insane, hoping for once they will do the book justice, but maybe this isnt the only reason we are insane. Movie when it comes to the consumption of literature materials, different people have different tastes and preferences.
1031 161 1094 629 476 242 1613 845 95 1639 62 885 297 1352 552 835 157 1665 1594 509 1181 568 481 468 312 240 1355 1425 772 1246 592 352